Biologia plantarum 66:46-55, 2022 | DOI: 10.32615/bp.2021.057
Selection of suitable reference genes for real-time qPCR gene expression in cauliflower under abiotic stress and methyl jasmonate treatment
- 1 Institute of Crop Sciences, Fujian Academy of Agricultural Science, Fuzhou, Fujian, 350013, P.R. China
- 2 Zhejiang Provincial Key Laboratory of Horticultural Plant Integrative Biology, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, 310058, P.R. China
Cauliflower is one of the most important popular vegetables in China. Cauliflower (Brassica oleracea L. var. botrytis) produces glucosinolates, which are secondary metabolites that have anti-cancer properties. The choice of suitable reference genes (RGs) for gene expression studies has a significant effect on experimental outcomes. In this study, we selected 15 candidates as RGs and analyzed them under heat, cold, drought, and salt stresses and methyl jasmonate (MeJA) treatment. The precision of the real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction data was assessed using four methods (geNorm, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and ΔCt). The results revealed that EF1-β and ACT7; ACT1, EF1-β, and TUB6; TUA2 and EF1-β; HIS and ACT7; and ACT7 and ACT3 were the most stable combinations of genes for heat stress, cold stress, drought stress, salt stress, and MeJA treatment, respectively. The expression stability of the RGs fluctuated under different experimental conditions. Choosing the optimal RG for the specific experiment is therefore essential. This work provides relevant information for further gene expression studies on cauliflower and other closely related species.
Keywords: Brassica oleracea var. botrytis, cold, drought, gene expression, heat, methyl jasmonate, salinity.
Received: February 3, 2021; Revised: September 10, 2021; Accepted: September 15, 2021; Published online: March 1, 2022 Show citation
| ACS | AIP | APA | ASA | Harvard | Chicago | Chicago Notes | IEEE | ISO690 | MLA | NLM | Turabian | Vancouver |
Supplementary files
| Download file | 6683_Lin_Suppl.pdf File size: 710.11 kB |
References
- Andersen, C.L., Jensen, J.L., Ørntoft, T.F.: Normalization of real-time quantitative reverse transcription - PCR data: a model-based variance estimation approach to identify genes suited for normalization, applied to bladder and colon cancer data sets. - Cancer Res. 64: 5245-5250, 2004.
Go to original source... - Arya, S., Jain, G., Upadhyay, S., Singh, H., Yadav, S., Dixit, S., Verma, P.: Reference genes validation in Phenacoccus solenopsis under various biotic and abiotic stress conditions. - Sci. Rep. 7: 13520, 2017.
Go to original source... - Bergès, S., Vile, D., Vazquez-Rovere, C., Blanc, S., Yvon, M., Bédiée, A., Rolland, G., Dauzat, M., Van Munster, M.: Interactions between drought and plant genotype change epidemiological traits of Cauliflower mosaic virus. - Front. Plant Sci. 9: 703, 2018.
Go to original source... - Borges, A., Tsai, S.M., Caldas, D.G.G.: Validation of reference genes for RT-qPCR normalization in common bean during biotic and abiotic stresses. - Plant Cell Rep. 31: 827-838, 2012.
Go to original source... - Bustin, S., Beaulieu, J.F., Huggett, J., Jaggi, R., Kibenge, F.S., Olsvik, P., Penning, L., Toegel, S.: MIQE précis: practical implementation of minimum standard guidelines for fluorescence-based quantitative real-time PCR experiments. - BMC mol. Biol. 11: 74, 2010.
Go to original source... - Cai, Z.M., Xie, G.F., Chen, Z.Y., Yuan, Y.F., Wang, W., Xie, Q., Guan, X.Y., Chen, Q.X., Chen, J.Q.: Genome-wide identification and validation of optimal reference genes for gene expression normalization in pear peel. - Plant Growth Regul. 92: 249-26, 2020.
Go to original source... - Chen, J.Q., Li, X.Y., Wang, D.Q., Li, L.T., Zhou, H.S., Liu, Z., Wu, J., Wang, P., Jiang, X.T., Fabrice, M., Zhang, S.L., Wu, J.Y.: Identification and testing of reference genes for gene expression analysis in pollen of Pyrus bretschneideri. - Sci. Hort. 190: 43-56, 2015.
Go to original source... - De Andrade, L., Brito, M., Junior, R., Marchiori, P., Nobile, P., Martins, A., Ribeiro, R., Creste, S.: Reference genes for normalization of qPCR assays in sugarcane plants under water deficit. - Plant Methods 13: 28, 2017.
Go to original source... - Deng, L.T., Wu, Y.L., Li, J.C., Ouyang, K.X., Ding, M.M., Zhang, J.J., Li, S.Q., Lin, M.F., Chen, H.B., Hu, X.S., Chen, X.Y.: Screening reliable reference genes for RT-qPCR analysis of gene expression in Moringa oleifera. - PLoS ONE 11: e0159458, 2016.
Go to original source... - Duan, M.M., Wang, J.L., Zhang, X.H., Yang, H.H., Wang, H.P., Qiu, Y., Song, J.P., Guo, Y.D., Li, X.X.: Identification of optimal reference genes for expression analysis in radish (Raphanus sativus L.) and its relatives based on expression stability. - Front. Plant. Sci. 8: 1605, 2017.
Go to original source... - Expósito-Rodríguez, M., Borges, A.A., Borges-Pérez, A., Pérez, J.A.: Selection of internal control genes for quantitative real-time RT-PCR studies during tomato development process. - BMC Plant Biol. 8: 131, 2008.
Go to original source... - Giuffrida, F., Angelo, M., PaoloMauro, R., Ferrante, A., Leonardi, C.: Cultivation under salt stress conditions influences postharvest quality and glucosinolates content of fresh-cut cauliflower. - Sci. Hort. 236: 166-174, 2018.
Go to original source... - Hong, S.Y., Seo, P.J., Yang, M.S., Xiang, F., Park, C.M.: Exploring valid reference genes for gene expression studies in Brachypodium distachyon by real-time PCR. - BMC Plant Biol. 8: 112, 2008.
Go to original source... - Huang, L., Yan, H., Jiang, X., Yin, G., Zhang, X., Qi, X., Zhang, Y., Yan, Y., Ma, X., Peng, Y.: Identification of candidate reference genes in perennial ryegrass for quantitative RT-PCR under various abiotic stress conditions. - PLoS ONE 9: e93724, 2014.
Go to original source... - Huggett, J., Dheda, K., Bustin, S., Zumla, A.: Real-time RT-PCR normalisation; strategies and considerations. - Genes Immunol. 6: 279-284, 2005.
Go to original source... - Kalisz, A., Sêkara, A., Smoleñ, S., Grabowska, A., Gil, J., Cebula, S.: Mineral composition of cauliflowers with differently coloured curds modified by the chilling of juvenile plants. - Sci. Hort. 232: 216-225, 2018.
Go to original source... - Kim, B.R., Nam, H.Y., Kim, S.U., Kim, S.I., Chang, Y.J.: Normalization of reverse transcription quantitative-PCR with housekeeping genes in rice. - Biotechnol. Lett. 25: 1869-1872, 2003.
Go to original source... - Li, J., Han, X., Wang, C., Qi, W., Zhang, W., Tang, L., Zhao, X.: Validation of suitable reference genes for qRT-PCR data in Achyranthes bidentata blume under different experimental conditions. - Front Plant Sci. 8: 776, 2017.
Go to original source... - Li, J., Jia, H.X., Han, X.J., Zhang, J., Sun, P., Lu, M.Z., Hu, J.J.: Selection of reliable reference genes for gene expression analysis under abiotic stresses in the desert biomass willow, Salix psammophila. - Front Plant Sci. 7: 1505, 2016a.
Go to original source... - Li, L., Li, N.W., Fang, H.L., Qi, X.W., Zhou, Y.F.: Selection and validation of reference genes for normalisation of gene expression in Glehnia littoralis. - Sci. Rep. 10: 7374, 2020a.
Go to original source... - Li, M., Xie, F., He, Q., Li, J., Liu, J., Sun, B., Luo, Y., Zhang, Y., Chen, Q., Zhang, F., Gong, R., Wang, Y., Wang, X., Tang, H.: Expression analysis of XTH in stem swelling of stem mustard and selection of reference genes. - Genes 11: 113, 2020b.
Go to original source... - Li, M.Y., Xiong, A.S., Wang, F., Xiong, A.S.: Suitable reference genes for accurate gene expression analysis in parsley (Petroselinum crispum) for abiotic stresses and hormone stimuli. - Front. Plant Sci. 7: 1263, 2016b.
Go to original source... - Liu, Q., Qi, X., Yan, H., Huang, L., Nie, G., Zhang, X.: Reference gene selection for quantitative real-time reverse- transcriptase PCR in annual ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum) subjected to various abiotic stresses. - Molecules 23: 172-188, 2018a.
Go to original source... - Liu, X., Guan, H.R., Song, M., Fu, Y.P., Han, X.M., Lei, M., Ren, J.Y., Guo, B., He, W., Wei, Y.H.: Reference gene selection for qRT-PCR assays in Stellera chamaejasme subjected to abiotic stresses and hormone treatments based on transcriptome datasets. - Peer J. 6: e4535, 2018b.
Go to original source... - Liu, Z., Ge, X., Wu, X., Kou, S., Chai, L., Guo, W.: Selection and validation of suitable reference genes for mRNA qRT-PCR analysis using somatic embryogenic cultures, floral and vegetative tissues in citrus. - Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult. 113: 469-481, 2013.
Go to original source... - Martins, P.K., Mafra, V.D., Vinecky, F., Basso, M.F., Da Cunha, B.A., Kobayashi, A.K., Molinari, H.B.: Selection of reliable reference genes for RT-qPCR analysis during developmental stages and abiotic stress in Setaria viridis. - Sci. Rep. 6: 28348, 2016.
Go to original source... - Mashabela, M.N., Maboko, M.M., Soundy, P., Sivakumar, D.: Variety specific responses of cauliflower varieties (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis) to different N application rates on yield, colour and ascorbic acid content at harvest. - Acta agr. scand. B. 68: 541-545, 2018.
Go to original source... - Nadai, C., Campanaro, S., Giacomini, A., Corich, V.: Selection and validation of reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR studies during Saccharomyces cerevisiae alcoholic fermentation in the presence of sulfite. - Int. J. Food Microbiol. 215: 49-56, 2015.
Go to original source... - Nerdy: Determination of sodium, potassium, magnesium, and calcium minerals level in fresh and boiled broccoli and cauliflower by atomic absorption spectrometry. - IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng. 288: 012113, 2018.
Go to original source... - Nguyen, D., Eamens, A., Grof, C.: Reference gene identification for reliable normalisation of quantitative RT-PCR data in Setaria viridis. - Plant Methods 14: 24, 2018.
Go to original source... - Nolan, T., Hands, R., Bustin, S.: Quantification of mRNA using real-time RT-PCR. - Nat. Protoc. 1: 1559-1582, 2006.
Go to original source... - Oda, A.M, Abdulkadhim, H., Jabuk, S., Hashim, R., Fadhil, I., Alaa, D., Kareem, A.: Green synthesis of silver nanoparticle by cauliflower extract: characterisation and antibacterial activity against storage. - IET Nanobiotechnol. 13: 74-79, 2019.
Go to original source... - Pfaffl, M., Tichopad, A., Prgomet, C., Neuvians, T.P.: Determination of stable housekeeping genes, differentially regulated target genes and sample integrity: BestKeeper-Excel-based tool using pair-wise correlations. - Biotechnol. Lett. 26: 509-515, 2004.
Go to original source... - Qu, R.J., Miao, Y.J., Cui, Y.J., Cao, Y.W., Zhou, Y., Tang, X.Q., Yang, J., Wang, F.Q.: Selection of reference genes for the quantitative real-time PCR normalization of gene expression in Isatis indigotica fortune. - BMC mol. Biol. 20: 9, 2019.
Go to original source... - Randhawa, G.J., Chhabra, R., Singh, M.: Molecular characterization of Bt cauliflower with multiplex PCR and validation of endogenous reference gene in Brassicaceae family. - Curr. Sci. India 96: 1729-1731, 2008.
- Schmittgen, T.D., Livak, K.J.: Analyzing real-time PCR data by the comparative CT method. - Nat. Protoc. 3: 1101, 2008.
Go to original source... - Sheng, X.G., Zhao, Z.Q., Yu, H.F., Wang, J.S., Zheng, C.F., Gu, H.H.: In-depth analysis of internal control genes for quantitative real-time PCR in Brassica oleracea var. botrytis. - Genet. mol. Res. 15: gmr.15038348, 2016.
Go to original source... - Shivhare, R., Lata, C.: Selection of suitable reference genes for assessing gene expression in pearl millet under different abiotic stresses and their combinations. - Sci. Rep. 6: 23036, 2016.
Go to original source... - Sun, H., Jiang, X., Sun, M., Cong, H., Qiao, F.: Evaluation of reference genes for normalizing RT-qPCR in leaves and suspension cells of Cephalotaxus hainanensis under various stimuli. - Plant Methods 15: 31, 2019.
Go to original source... - Sun, X.X., Bucher, J., Ji, Y., Van Dijk, A.D.J., Immink, R.G.H., Bonnema, G.: Effect of ambient temperature fluctuation on the timing of the transition to the generative stage in cauliflower. - Environ. exp. Bot. 155: 742-750, 2018.
Go to original source... - Tang, J., Qing, Q., Liu, Q.Q., Yuan, H.Y., Zhang, Y.X., Wang, W.L., Su, Z., Huang, S.Z.: Molecular cloning and characterization of a novel salt-specific responsive WRKY transcription factor gene IlWRKY2 from the halophyte Iris lactea var. chinensis. - Genes Genom. 40: 893-903, 2018.
Go to original source... - Thorwarth, P.T., Yousef, E.A.A., Schmid, K.J.: Genomic prediction and association mapping of curd-related traits in gene bank accessions of cauliflower. - G3: Genes, Genomics Gent. 8: 707-718, 2018.
Go to original source... - Vandesompele, J., De Preter, K., Pattyn, F., Poppe, B., Van Roy, N., De Paepe, A., Speleman, F.: Accurate normalization of real-time quantitative RT-PCR data by geometric averaging of multiple internal control genes. - Genome Biol. 3: research0034, 2002.
Go to original source... - Wang, C., Cui, H.M., Huang, T.H., Liu, T.K., Hou, X.L., Li, Y.: Identification and validation of reference genes for qRT-PCR analysis in non-heading chinese cabbage flowers. - Front Plant Sci. 7: 811, 2016.
Go to original source... - Wang, X.: Vegetable Breeding and Seed Production of Cruciferae. - Chemical Industry Press, Beijing 2012.
- Wang, Z., Xu, J., Liu, Y., Chen, J., Lin, H., Huang, Y., Bian, X., Zhao, Y.: Selection and validation of appropriate reference genes for real-time quantitative PCR analysis in Momordica charantia. - Phytochemistry 164: 1-11, 2019.
Go to original source... - Wei, M., Chen, Y.X., Zhang, M.Q., Yang, J.L., Lu, H., Zhang, X., Li, C.H.: Selection and validation of reference genes for the qRT-PCR assays of Populus ussuriensis gene expression under abiotic stresses and related ABA treatment. - Forests 11: 476, 2020.
Go to original source... - Xu, W., Dong, Y.N., Yu, Y.C., Xing, Y.X., Li, X.W., Zhang, X., Hou, X.J., Sun, X.L.: Identification and evaluation of reliable reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR analysis in tea plants under differential biotic stresses. - Sci. Rep. 10: 2429, 2020.
Go to original source... - Xu, Y., Li, H., Li, X., Lin, J., Wang, Z., Yang, Q., Chang, Y.: Systematic selection and validation of appropriate reference genes for gene expression studies by quantitative real-time PCR in pear. - Acta Physiol. Plant. 37: 40, 2015.
Go to original source... - Xu, X.Y., Yang, Z.P., Sun, X.L., Zhang, L.G., Fang, Z.Y.: Selection of reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR during flower bud development in CMS7311 of heading Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis). - Acta Physiol. Plant. 36: 809-814, 2014.
Go to original source... - Ye, X., Zhang, F.M., Tao, Y.H., Song, S.W., Fang, J.B.: Reference gene selection for quantitative real-time PCR normalization in different cherry genotypes, developmental stages and organs. - Sci. Hort. 181: 182-188, 2015.
Go to original source... - You, Y., Zhang, L., Li, P., Yang, C., Ma, F.: Selection of reliable reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR analysis in plum (Prunus salicina Lindl.) under different postharvest treatments. - Sci. Hort. 210: 285-293, 2016.
Go to original source... - Yousef, E.A.A, Müller, T., Börner, A., Schmid, K.J.: Comparative analysis of genetic diversity and differentiation of cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis) accessions from two ex situ genebanks. - PLoS ONE 13: e0192062, 2018.
Go to original source... - Yu, J.J., Su, Y., Sun, J.Y., Liu, J.R., Li, Z.Y., Zhang, B.H.: Selection of stable reference genes for gene expression analysis in sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas L.). - Mol. cell. Probes 53: 101610, 2020.
Go to original source... - Zeng, A.S., Xu, Y.Y., Song, L.X., Li, J.Q., Ji, Y.: Validation of suitable reference genes for qRT-PCR in cabbage (Brassica oleracea L.) under different abiotic stress experimental conditions. - J. Plant Biochem. Biol. 30: 184-195, 2021.
Go to original source... - Zhang, Z.P., Li, C.J., Zhang, J.Q., Chen, F., Gong, Y.F., Li, Y.R., Su, Y.J., Wei, Y.J., Zhao, Y.C.: Selection of the reference gene for expression normalization in Papaver somniferum L. under abiotic stress and hormone treatment. - Genes 11: 124, 2020.
Go to original source... - Zhang, Y., Han, X., Chen, S., Zheng, L., He, X., Liu, M., Qiao, G., Wang, Y., Zhuo, R.: Selection of suitable reference genes for quantitative real-time PCR gene expression analysis in Salix matsudana under different abiotic stresses. - Sci. Rep. 7: 40290, 2017.
Go to original source...



